Julia_Wise🔸

Community liaison @ Centre for Effective Altruism
13763 karmaJoined Boston, MA, USAjuliawise.net

Bio

Participation
1

I'm one of the contact people for the effective altruism community. I work at CEA as a community liaison, trying to support the EA community in addressing problems and being a healthy and welcoming community.

Please feel free to contact me at julia.wise@centreforeffectivealtruism.org.

Besides effective altruism, I'm interested in folk dance and trying to keep up with my three children.

Sequences
1

2023 project on reforms in EA

Comments
500

Topic contributions
5

Want to share this in the Boston EA Facebook group? https://www.facebook.com/groups/1552072601751317

Nice piece, but I feel like many of the examples were cherry-picked to be alarming.

I definitely don't want to frame this as primarily my work — I think projects like Magnify have played more of a role.  But thank you for the kind words!

I also think it's really hard to tell what contributes to change or lack of change in demographics.

Thanks, I've changed it to an article about them.

Thanks for the correction! I've adjusted the entries, do let me know if there's anything still not right.

I agree there's something here, but I think you're overselling the theory's level of backup. It really lost me at the ADHD part.

My summary from when I looked at this when trying to figure out orthodontics for my kid:
"Orthodontists evaluated Norwegian skulls from 500 years ago and from now. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17561048/ "Only 36% of the medieval group showed objective assessed needs for orthodontic treatment, compared with 65% of the present-day sample." Similar study in China, with a 4000-year-old sample because China. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22340477/"
This made me think that in pre-modern environments, tooth/jaw problems were better but not absent.

Getting kids to do things differently (holding their body differently, eating different foods) seems pretty hard. One more tractable intervention could be informing parents as consumers of orthodontics that there are downsides to making the mouth smaller. E.g. when I talked to different orthodontists, one proposed pulling teeth to reduce teeth crowding, while the others wanted to use an expander to make more room.

Minor suggestion: you could link to the calculator earlier in this post. I was curious to see it sooner!

>btw your number should be 12,000 on the 88% cure rate, not 22,000.
Thanks, you're right!

Sorry, I realize this is in the weeds, but I don't see where they say they're building up obstetric health infrastructure at all. They work with surgical teams to facilitate more reparative surgeries, but it's not clear to me that those surgeons are providing any care before or during births. Again, repairs rather than prevention may just be the most cost-effective way to make immediate progress on this problem — I don't mean that it's not a good strategy! 

I was looking at the Vision page which describes "in it to end it" several times as their vision (but vision statements are meant to be aspirational rather than realistic). An 88% cure rate on 100,000 surgeries is still 22,000 [edit, should be 12,000] uncured patients even after treatment, so I do think there's a gap between the vision and what one should expect in a practical sense.

Load more